|
HOW PUBLIC SCHOOLS HAVE PROMOTED THE COMMON
GOOD IN THE UNITED STATES
Public education plays a vital role in America’s democratic society,
and the public spirited missions of public schools remain essential
today, according to a new report by the Center on Education Policy.
The report, "Why We Still Need Public Schools: Public Education for
the Common Good," highlights the history and importance of public
education in the United States, dating back to its establishment as
a necessary institution for the young republic and Horace Mann’s
efforts to promote a common school for all. The report focuses on:
|
1.
|
How and why the U.S. system of public education came into
being; |
|
2.
|
The six core public missions that public schools have
been expected to fulfill, such as unifying a diverse population,
preparing people for democratic citizenship, and ensuring equal
opportunities for all children; and |
|
3.
|
Why these missions are relevant today and why the nation
must maintain them while pursuing reforms to help all schools live up to
these core ideals. |
The report is part of the Center’s ongoing efforts to help
Americans better understand the role of public education in a
democracy and the need to improve the academic quality of public
schools.
THE PUBLIC SEEMS TO GET IT
While poring over the data from the latest Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup
Poll of the Public’s Attitudes Toward the Public Schools, analysts
were amazed, as they are every year, at the public’s ability to
separate myth from reality and arrive at accurate assessments of
their public schools. When asked how to improve public education in
America, seven of 10 Americans said "reform the existing public
school system" rather than "find an alternative system." Alternative
opportunities don't command much interest, writes William J. Bushaw
in The School Administrator. Five of 10 Americans graded their
community schools with an A or a B. It seems the public and
particularly public school parents aren't ready to buy the notion
that schools don't work. Further, over last three years, the PDK/Gallup
poll documents that the American public increasingly opposes the use
of vouchers for children to attend private schools. We find
ourselves wondering why the public understands this while our
leaders in Washington, D.C., do not. Added to this disconnection
between policymakers and the public is the unfolding tragedy of the
No Child Left Behind Act. Praiseworthy goals are encased in an
implementation plan so ill-conceived that the public overwhelmingly
rejects every strategy used. Even more damning, this year six of 10
Americans say NCLB is either hurting or making no difference in
their community’s schools. That this reality is being ignored makes
it likely that NCLB, for all its bright promise, will lead to
limited gains and may actually do harm to our schools. Bushaw wishes
the policymakers in Washington would acknowledge that the American
public likes its community schools and that the key to helping our
nation’s schools get even better is to develop policies that build
on this existing base of public support. Our political leaders
ignore the public’s desires, inflict punitive strategies on the
public schools and promote alternatives that lack public support.
IVAN PRAYS FOR A SUPERMAN TO FIND HIM A HOME
For a special report, ABC News "20/20" followed the lives of three
children growing up in Camden, N.J.: Billy Joe, Moochie and Ivan. In
a public park, Diane Sawyer met Ivan Stevens; his mother, Precious;
and his little brother, Imere. Sometimes they spent the whole day
dirty, hungry and homeless, with no place to go. The owner of an
illegal boarding house occasionally gave them a place to sleep. He
padlocked the refrigerator to keep them from taking food, and all
three of them slept on one chair, surrounded by clutter and roaches.
Ivan wished he could be Superman and fly on someone's back to find
his family a home. "Superman" had also heard of kindergarten. "I
wanna go to school so bad. I wanna read," Ivan said excitedly on the
first day of school. On the way to school, though, reality set in,
and Ivan realized that for the first time he'd be without his
mother's protection. He was also afraid that the other kids would be
mean to him, and he started to cry. "It's alright. ... You can be
scared," his mother said. "But you gotta be a big boy. I'm not going
to ever leave you where you [are] not welcome." The teacher welcomed
Ivan to the class, and he reluctantly said goodbye to his mother. A
school administrator sat down and helped him get started. "Do you
know your threes?" asked the school district supervisor. Ivan easily
counted the three wheels on the tricycle, but he was stumped when
asked how many meals you are supposed to eat in a day. Ivan, who has
gone to school without eating breakfast, was puzzled. The words
"lunch" and "dinner" seemed foreign to him. In fact, at the end of
the day, when commenting on how great kindergarten was, he proudly
showed the extra juice box he was able to take with him. "I'm not
going to cry no more, and I'm going to be a big boy," he said,
noting that he also had eaten cheese with bread and applesauce. The
bravery of these children fighting poverty and fear everyday will
both amaze and enrage you.
LOCAL EDUCATION FUND SAYS SCHOOLS MUST PAY
MORE ATTENTION INSIDE CLASSROOMS
More attention should be paid to what happens inside Wake County’s
classrooms, and not only to how or where more classroom space is
built, according to an annual independent review of the public’s
schools from Wake Education Partnership, a local education fund. The
annual Quality Matters report has been issued annually since 2001.
"Most of our community’s attention in 2006 centered on constructing
schools and adding seats for new students," said Jay Silver, chair
of the Quality Matters Committee and partner with Kilpatrick
Stockton. "While these issues are important, they draw public
attention away from critical issues related to student performance.
The next level of success will not come easily. The challenges on
the horizon require time, attention, and even money -- all of which
are in limited supply." Despite past successes in Wake County public
school performance, significant challenges continue to confront
public schools, including enrollment growth, student achievement and
school funding. Quality Matters is the result of a year-long study
of key issues related to academic performance and funding of the
Wake County Public School System. It provides data, research and
recommendations for what must be done by the community to ensure
that students can learn better, teachers can teach better, and how
school leaders can be more effective in building a system where
quality truly continues to matter. The report is a collaborative
advocacy effort researched and written by business, civic, and
education leaders convened by Wake Education Partnership
ACADEMIC GAINS NOT SUPERIOR AMONG STUDENTS
ENROLLED IN PRIVATELY RUN PUBLIC SCHOOLS
Academic improvement among students attending Philadelphia public
schools managed by private operators kept pace, but did not exceed,
the achievement gains of students in the rest of the district in the
past four years, according to an analysis issued today by the RAND
Corporation and Research for Action. While significant academic
gains were made from 2002 to 2006 by students across Philadelphia,
private managers who were given extra funds to run 45 elementary and
middle schools did not achieve additional gains exceeding
district-wide trends, according to researchers. Researchers say that
their findings have implications for other regions that are
considering private management of public schools and that the effort
in Philadelphia suggests the challenges of implementing private
management on a large scale. Philadelphia is the site of the largest
experiment in the private management of public schools in the United
States. "Schools in Philadelphia have shown strong improvement that
has been reflected widely across the district," said Jolley
Christman, a co-author of the report. "But our findings show the
investment in private management of schools has not paid the
expected dividends." Advocates of private management of public
schools say the approach works best when private managers have full
control of campuses and parents decide where to enroll their
children -- measures that were not fully implemented in
Philadelphia. Funding for the study was provided by the Annenberg
Foundation, the William Penn Foundation and the Accountability
Review Council for the School District of Philadelphia. The
presentation of findings was hosted by the Philadelphia Education
Fund, a local education fund. The report, "State Takeover, School
Restructuring, Private Management, and Student Achievement in
Philadelphia," was co-authored Ron Zimmer of RAND and Suzanne Blanc
of Research for Action.
WHY I WON'T GO TO THE PROM
April Daley, a high school senior, writes in New Youth Connections
that she doesn't plan to attend her prom. Her friends have tried to
convince her that prom is pivotal in a teen's life, a rite of
passage, and that there will never be an event like prom ever again.
She doesn't see her prom as a rite of passage into adulthood. Prom
was created to teach teens the poise and composure they would need
as adults. But it has evolved into a night that's often devoid of
poise and composure. Since the 1980s, prom has been less about
learning manners and more about celebration, drinking and sex.
Instead of celebrating their readiness to take on adult
responsibilities, teens now seem to celebrate the freedom to not be
responsible for their actions. When prom first started, teens wore
their Sunday best, which they usually already owned. They didn't go
out to buy dresses or rent tuxes or limos. It was more about the
event than what you wore to the event. But now, there are seating
charts for the limo. There are nails to be painted, time to be spent
under the hair dryer for elaborate up-dos, prom tickets to buy,
corsages and boutonnieres to color-coordinate and accessories to
pull it all together. Prom may have its merits, but it is no longer
a rite of passage, it is just a fancy party.
STUDENT EDUCATIONAL & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT FOR
SUCCESS
A school security initiative and enhanced teacher pay were among
several new education programs outlined by Gov. Joe Manchin III in
his recent State of the State address. Gov. Manchin, a Democrat,
said that West Virginia should focus its attention on improving its
response to school emergencies. He is requesting $10 million for the
creation of a school-access safety-grant initiative, headed by the
School Building Authority, to better secure and monitor access to
public schools. Overall, the governor is proposing to spend $1.81
billion on K-12 education in a fiscal 2008 state budget of $3.87
billion. The governor also recommended a 2.5 percent
across-the-board pay raise for all teachers, a minimum salary of
$30,000 for all full-time teachers, and an increase in the salary
bonus for teachers who earn certification from the National Board
for Professional Teaching Standards. In addition, he outlined a new
project called Student Educational and Economic Development for
Success, or SEEDS, a public-private partnership between the state
and the Education Alliance, a local education fund. SEEDS aims to
help struggling schools through the use of established business
practices, such as time management, goal-setting, and performance
measurement, reports Laura Greifner in Education Week.
CHILDREN LEFT BEHIND: HOW METROPOLITAN AREAS ARE FAILING
AMERICA’S CHILDREN
The DiversityData project identifies metropolitan area indicators of
diversity, opportunity, quality of life and health for various
racial and ethnic population groups. This website is now available
to a wide variety of potential users interested in describing,
profiling and ranking U.S. metros in terms of quality of life. The
indicators provide a scorecard on diversity and opportunity, and
allow researchers, policymakers and community advocates to compare
metro areas and to help them advocate for policy action and social
change. The choice of indicators was grounded in recent work on
urban inequality and health inequality, which points to the
significance of racial/ethnic disparities in health, educational,
employment and housing opportunities across metro areas. The project
challenges urban researchers, policymakers and activists to define
quality of life and health broadly -- to include opportunities for
good schools, housing, jobs, wages, health and social services, and
safe neighborhoods -- to compare achievement across metros, and to
make continuous changes to keep metropolitan life healthy for all
populations. Public policies may enhance or harm the well-being of
diverse populations. Important policy areas include neighborhood
integration, residential mobility, anti-discrimination in housing,
urban renewal, school quality and economic opportunities. A new
report from the Harvard School of Public Health scores the living
conditions experienced by children in the 100 largest U.S.
metropolitan areas. It reveals a consistently bleak picture for
black and Hispanic children compared to white and Asian children and
suggests approaches to address some of the factors behind whether or
not a child thrives.
REVIEWING THE SCHOOL CUPCAKE BAN
For several months now, many schools have been taking a hard line on
hard candy -- as well as the cookies and cream-filled confections
that used to seem like harmless splurges in the course of a child's
day. But many parents and health advocates wish schools would devote
as much energy to reforming the quality of lunch fare as they've
invested in ridding campuses of sodas and snacks. The controversy
over contraband foods is the result of a federal law requiring every
school system in the National School Lunch and School Breakfast
programs to write a "wellness policy" by July of last year.
Washington, D.C.'s Board of Education still has not adopted final
rules codifying its wellness policy, although officials insist that
many of the programs are already taking place in the schools.
Spotsylvania County (VA) schools have crafted what is perhaps the
most comprehensive wellness policy in the region, ranging from
curbing what's sold in vending machines to providing nutritional
counseling. Implementing that detailed action plan keeps Nancy
Farrell, the school system's full-time "wellness dietitian," on her
toes. Instead of teachers having ice cream parties or giving out
candy bars or pizza coupons as rewards, reports Karen Pallarito in
The Washington Post, Farrell encourages them to hold class outdoors,
hand out homework passes or offer verbal praise. She also adorns
school hallways with posters featuring kids, teachers and principals
eating healthy food. Those things are all well and good, school
health advocates agree, but they remain frustrated by the slow pace
of achieving broader school lunch reforms.
STUDENTS GET MORE NEWS IN CLASSROOM FROM INTERNET THAN TV OR
NEWSPAPERS
A new survey by the Carnegie-Knight Task Force at Harvard University
shows a strong movement in America’s classrooms toward the use of
Internet-based news and away from the use of newspapers and
television news, a trend that is virtually certain to continue. The
study also shows that teachers, as they have moved to the Internet,
have switched from using hundreds of local news outlets to making
use of a small number of national ones. Internet-based news in the
classroom is dominated by the websites of a few top news
organizations including CNN, PBS, and The New York Times. In fact,
the classroom use of non-U.S. websites, such as BBC’s, even exceeds
the use of local TV or newspaper sites. The report is based on
parallel national surveys of over 1,250 social studies, civics, and
government teachers in grades 5 through 12, as well as several
hundred Newspaper-in-Education (NIE) program directors at daily
newspapers. The survey of teachers showed that half are making
greater use of news today than they were a few years ago, an
increase attributable to developments outside the school such as the
war on terrorism and the fighting in Iraq. For over 20 years,
hundreds of large and small U.S. dailies have provided free or
reduced rate copies of their newspapers for classroom use by
students through the Newspapers-in-Education program. Touted as a
means of improving students’ reading, spelling, and writing skills
as well as contributing to civic education, it has also been a way
to encourage students to become lifelong newspaper readers. Most
newspapers continue to promote hard-copy newspapers at a time when
teachers and students are moving online.
LIVING NEAR BUSY ROADS TIED TO KIDS' LUNG RISK
Growing up near a freeway stunts a child's breathing capacity for a
lifetime, significantly increasing the risk of serious lung and
heart diseases later in life, according to researchers who monitored
thousands of Southern California children for up to eight years. The
landmark study, led by a team of University of Southern California
scientists and released Thursday, delivers a sobering answer to a
long-standing question about the health effects of being raised near
a busy roadway where air is chronically polluted. These children not
only are more likely to develop asthma, but their lung development
can be permanently cut short, increasing their odds of having a
heart attack or a life-threatening respiratory condition, starting
as early as their 50s. The findings carry profound policy
implications nationwide for agencies that monitor and regulate air
pollution, for locally elected officials who determine where to
place new roads and housing tracts, and for education officials who
buy property for new schools, reports Chris Bowman in The Sacramento
Bee.
CALIFORNIA ARTS EDUCATION HANDBOOK NOW ONLINE
The purpose of The Insider’s Guide to Arts Education Planning is to
provide a hands-on, how-to planning process for schools, districts
and counties. Field tested best practices, innovative ideas,
templates and strategies are offered here as a guide to navigate
arts education planning. The California Alliance for Arts Education
is pleased to offer this guide as a tool and catalyst for strategic
thinking and district wide planning. The Guide grows out of the
Community Arts Education Project (CAEP), a 2001 jointly sponsored
initiative of the California Alliance for Arts Education (CAAE) and
the California State PTA. The original project was conceived as both
a guidebook and a hands-on technical assistance process that enables
districts to assess current arts learning programs and funding
allocations, identify gaps in delivery, and create strategic plans
that will ensure equitable access for all students in each of the
four arts disciplines.
NEW STUDY OF GATES SMALL HIGH SCHOOL IN NYC
In 2002, New York City initiated an ambitious campaign to transform
its public high schools, which, on average, had been graduating only
half their students. The lowest performing high schools in the City
were replaced with new, smaller schools intended to prepare students
for successful postsecondary study or work. But, have smaller high
schools worked? A new WestEd study, prepared for the Bill & Melinda
Gates Foundation, examines 14 of the new, smaller high schools that
graduated their first class in June, 2006. Data indicate that
attendance is high, ninth grade promotion rates are high, and a
majority of students are graduating. A significant number of those
graduates are applying to and being accepted by postsecondary
institutions, over half of whom will be the first in their family to
attend college. The report, "Rethinking High School: Inaugural
Graduations at New York City's New High Schools," provides a
snapshot of the promise and impact of these small high schools in
the lives of adolescent learners from some of New York's most
underserved communities.
PUBLIC SCHOOL PRINCIPALS REPORT ON THEIR
SCHOOL FACILITIES
This new report from the National Center for Education Statistics
provides information about principals' satisfaction with various
environmental factors in their schools, and the extent to which they
perceive those factors as interfering with the ability of the school
to deliver instruction. The report also describes the extent of the
match between the enrollment and the capacity of the school
buildings, approaches for coping with overcrowding, the ways in
which schools use portable (temporary) buildings and reasons for
using them, and the availability of dedicated rooms or facilities
for particular subjects (such as science labs or music rooms) and
the extent to which these facilities are perceived to support
instruction. Major findings (from latest 2005 data) include: More
than half of the principals reported that their school had fewer
students than the school’s design capacity: 21 percent said their
school was underenrolled by more than 25 percent, and 38 percent
said their school was underenrolled by between 6 and 25 percent. The
remaining schools included those that had enrollments within 5
percent of their capacity (22 percent) and those that were
overenrolled (10 percent were overenrolled by between 6 to 25
percent above their capacity, and 8 percent by more than 25 percent
of their design capacity). Those schools that principals described
as overcrowded used a variety of approaches to deal with the
overcrowding: using portable classrooms (78 percent), converting
non-classroom space into classrooms (53 percent), increasing class
sizes (44 percent), building new permanent buildings or additions to
existing buildings (35 percent), using off-site instructional
facilities (5 percent), or other approaches (12 percent).
DOES SCHOOL CHOICE INCREASE PARENT INVOLVEMENT?
Choice proponents argue that allowing parents to choose schools that
match their preferences reduces local conflicts and encourages
effective school management practices. As a result, parents are more
willing to participate in school activities. A new paper by Jack
Buckley uses data from the National Household Education Survey (NHES)
to compare parent involvement in four types of schools: assigned
public, chosen public, non-religious private, and religious private.
Descriptive statistics suggest that attendance at school meetings
and events and participation in volunteering and fundraising is
greater in schools of choice. However, more advanced statistical
methods that control for family background characteristics produce
different outcomes. Public schools of choice appear to have no
effect on parent attendance at school meetings and events, but
provide a substantial boost to parent volunteering. Private secular
schools show a decline in parent attendance at school events, but an
increase in parent volunteering. Most interesting, private religious
schools are found to decrease parent involvement across all
measures. |